Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Developers whine about 7 line extension

From NY1:

"The residents feel like they moved here with the expectation that we would have a subway stop at 41st Street and 10th Avenue, and without it, it's hard to see how this can ever feel like a neighborhood," says Jay Marcus, the co-chair of the transportation committee for Manhattan's Community Board 4.

After plans for the station were dropped, that left only one stop along the 7 subway extension, at 34th Street and 11th Avenue, but the train will still pass through the 41st Street and 10th Avenue site.

Now that the boring machines are in the ground and approaching the area, the Real Estate Board of New York and the community are coming together in a last-minute effort to reinstate the original plan. They are asking that at least the shell of the station be cut out now while the machines are in place, or they fear the opportunity will be lost forever.

REBNY Chairman Mary Ann Tighe, who is working to help secure funding for the project, says future development in the neighborhood depends on it.

As to the issue of property value, many residents moved to the area under the assumption that there would eventually be a subway stop nearby. Now many fear they won't get the same return in their investment.

Some local developers may be able to kick in some private funds to the subway extension, but estimates for the shell alone are around $500 million.

A City Hall spokesperson says the city is already paying for the 7 extension and is in no position to pay for the shell.

Tighe says they know the funds for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and state are tight, so the community is calling on elected officials in Washington, D.C. to find federal dollars. They are also signing a petition at

So we should spend hundreds of millions of dollars to bail out property flippers and developers? Puh-leeze! There are plenty of good neighborhoods in this city without a subway station. But you folks already have one 2 blocks east, where almost every line in the city stops. For Christ's sake, shut up. No sympathy here, especially when we're running out of money for this as it is, and this is going on:


Anonymous said...

If the developers want to foot the bill for the 10th Avenue station, let them build it. They'll probably get it done in less time and cost than the MTA.

Remember: the city's first subway was also privately-owned, and built in less time and cost.

Anonymous said...

"Some local developers may be able to kick in some private funds to the subway extension, but estimates for the shell alone are around $500 million."

So why can't TDC/Rockefeller kick in some private $$ to extend the #7 Main Street-Flushing Station when they're adding 69 stories & 1 million sq ft to the nabe? Is Rockefeller outta $$?