They’re starting to run out of excuses.
The mayor and police have repeatedly blamed a coronavirus-related
court shutdown for the explosion of gun violence rocking the city — but
firearms cases are making their way through the criminal justice system
at the same rate as last year, a Post investigation shows.
The revelations come after The Post showed that the NYPD’s own data did not support those claims that bail reform and early prison releases over coronavirus were driving the spike.
“It’s a combination of things — bail reform, COVID releases from
prison, court shutdown, which has Rikers [Island] at half of where they
were,” Chief of Department Terence Monahan said in a July 6 press
briefing, seeking to explain the 70-percent rise in shootings this year.
Commissioner Dermot Shea and Mayor de Blasio have also blamed court
closure for the uptick, with Shea calling the tie “indisputable” on
Monday.
But the data tells another story.
In December 2019, as the city officials touted a record-breaking low
in shootings, there were 2,285 open gun cases in Gotham with 13 percent
of suspects awaiting trial, according to an analysis by The Post.
In July 2020, with shootings skyrocketing to 1990s-like levels, the
courts had 2,181 open firearms cases and 10 percent in lockup — or 104
fewer pending gun cases, the data shows.
Additionally, of the 1,957 people facing gun charges out on the
streets in July — which is 27 fewer than in December — only 2 percent,
or 39 people, were busted again for a firearm, according to the data
obtained by The Post.
There were also more gun and murder arraignments from April to June
compared to October through December last year, with 819 over the
three-month period this year compared to 642 last year, court data
shows.
NY Post
The buck continues to stop everywhere but on Mayor Bill de Blasio’s desk.
Hizzoner once again attacked the messenger Thursday rather than address a new Post article that found firearms cases are going through the criminal justice system at the
same rate as last year — refuting his claims that a coronavirus-related
court shutdown is most responsible for this summer’s surge in shootings
“I have not seen The Post article and I don’t always get accuracy
from that publication,” de Blasio sniffed during a virtual City Hall
press briefing when asked about the damning piece by a Wall Street
Journal reporter.
In December 2019, there were 2,285 open gun cases in Gotham with 13
percent of suspects awaiting trial, according to the Post analysis based
on NYPD and court data. In July 2020, the courts had 2,181 open
firearms cases and 10 percent in lockup — or 104 fewer pending gun
cases, the data shows.
There were also more gun and murder arraignments from April to June
compared to October through December last year, with 819 over the
three-month period this year compared to 642 last year, court data
shows.
De Blasio tried to discredit those numbers — before realizing they came from his own police department.
“Anyone can try and manipulate a statistic,” he said.
When the Journal reporter pointed out the data were NYPD statistics, de Blasio refused to back down.
“It’s a publication that historically has provided inaccurate
information. It may be accurate statistics in this case, but I’m just
not going to be gentle about the point that when there is a history of
inaccuracy and an axe to grind it’s worth saying,” de Blasio fumed at
The Post, rather than addressing the issue at hand.
“There is no one claiming the court system is functioning as normal. There’s just no one doing it,” de Blasio flailed.