Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Call boxes are here to stay

From the NY Times:

A federal judge in Manhattan has refused to allow the Bloomberg administration to eliminate 15,000 emergency-help boxes from New York’s streets, saying the city’s proposed alternative involving public pay phones is not adequate because it would discriminate against the deaf and hearing-impaired.

The Bloomberg administration last year asked the judge, Robert W. Sweet of Federal District Court, to lift a 1996 injunction that blocked a similar attempt by the city to remove its existing street alarm boxes.

In its request, the city estimated that deactivation of the street-box system would save $6.3 million a year. It also argued that use of the boxes had declined substantially because of cellphones, and that about 85 percent of calls were false alarms. The city proposed an alternative of public pay phones combined with a tapping protocol that would allow deaf and hearing-impaired callers to signal whether they needed police or fire services.

But Judge Sweet, in a decision filed Monday, said that the number of pay phones had declined substantially, that they were not always well maintained, and that the tapping protocol had not been tested with the pay-phone system. “The injunction remains an equitable solution,” he wrote.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Yeah!!!! Again Bloomberg knocked down.

Anonymous said...

What good is Bloomberg being knocked down if its costing taxpayers millions unnecessarily?

Anonymous said...

When was the last time a real alarm was given by these boxes ahead of a 911 call for the same real fire?

Anonymous said...

I would like to know how the .... does it cost 6.3 miilion a year to keep them. Sounds like more fishy accounting to me.

Anonymous said...

In queens(Bellerose) some one painted all of them. ThEY LOOK BEAUTIFUL. tHank you who ever did them for Sept 11...