THE CITY
The city’s canopy of more than 2.6 million street and
park trees will have to wait for scheduled prunings due to new budget
cuts — a move slammed by a former Parks Department commissioner as
“foolish” and dangerous.
The Fiscal 2021 Executive Plan includes a budget
reduction of $7.2 million for tree pruning contracts, leaving about $1.5
million for the job. City trees are generally trimmed every seven to 10
years.
Park advocates and government officials, pointing to past incidents where people were severely injured — or worse — by plummeting branches, sounded the alarm over the cuts.
“The problem with not pruning is if a limb falls from a
tall tree, it can cause tremendous damage. It can kill people,” said
Adrian Benepe, who served as Parks commissioner from 2002 to 2012.
“It’s a meaningless cut that could cause damage both to the trees and to people.”
After the city slashed tree-pruning funding in 2010,
tree-related injury claims soared. By delaying pruning contracts, the
city saved $1 million — but settlement costs neared $15 million, records
show.
“One bad tree limb fall wipes out all your savings,” said Benepe. “This saving is pennywise and pound foolish.”
During 2010, the city pruned less than 30,000
street trees — 50,000 fewer trees than the year before. Full funding
for the Parks pruning program wasn’t restored until FY2013 when the
10-year pruning cycle was reinstated.
Claims
for injuries caused by trees increased by 92% — from just under 400
claims to over 700 — during the period of reduced pruning and
maintenance. In some community districts outside Manhattan claims
increased by 590%, according to a 2015 ClaimStat report by City Comptroller Scott Stringer.
In 2015, Stringer told the City Council that there is a
direct correlation between million-dollar legal claims and the amount of
money the city allocates for tree pruning each year.
Reduced tree pruning isn’t synonymous with dangerous
conditions, said Dan Kastanis, a Parks Department spokesperson. “Tree
pruning is important, but inspections keep people safe, and proactive
tree inspections are continuing in every borough, every day,” he said.