The Village Sun Bowing to political pressure and in the face of numerous lawsuits,
Governor Hochul on Wednesday declared that the Manhattan congestion
pricing plan is on an “indefinite pause.”
“After careful consideration I have come to the difficult decision
that implementing the planned congestion pricing system risks too many
unintended consequences,” Hochul said. “I have directed the M.T.A. to
indefinitely pause the program.”
The Metropolitan Transportation’s traffic-tolling plan was set to
start later this month on June 30. It would have walloped car drivers
with a $15 once-a-day fee for driving into Manhattan south of 60th
Street ($3.75 during off-peak hours) — and trucks with repeated fees of
$24 to $36 for each time they entered the zone.
However, the scheme faced eight lawsuits, with plaintiffs ranging
from New Jersey, to the teachers union to Chinatown merchants and Lower
East Side residents, all of whom said the plan’s financial impact would
be unfair and onerous. Among the top arguments was that a comprehensive
environmental impact statement, or E.I.S., for the sweeping,
first-in-the-nation plan was shockingly never done.
Retired judge and former Councilmember Kathryn Freed, who lives on the Lower East Side and is a plaintiff on a class-action lawsuit against congestion pricing, has become a sort of poster person for the opposition. Yet, she described her reaction to the plan’s shelving as “mixed.”
“I’m not one of the people who’s crazy pro-car or whatever,” she
said. “The whole thing is a mess. I don’t know what Hochul was waiting
for — it was massively unpopular.”
Indeed, according to a recent Siena College survey, 63 percent of New
Yorkers statewide and 64 percent of Big Apple residents oppose the
Manhattan congestion pricing plan, with opposition in the suburbs even
higher at 72 percent. Fourteen percent said they would not come to
Manhattan as often due to the toll.
At the urging of then-Governor Cuomo, the state Legislature passed
congestion pricing into law five years ago, with the target of raising a
total of $15 billion — at a clip of $1 billion per year — for the
constantly cash-poor transit agency.